Sunday, December 3, 2023
  • Login
Africa360 Degrees
  • Africa
    • All
    • News
    • Politics
    Unravelling the Tapestry of Ethnic Tension in Africa: We are all Racists!

    Unravelling the Tapestry of Ethnic Tension in Africa: We are all Racists!

    Editorial: A Letter to Rwanda

    Editorial: A Letter to Rwanda

    The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

    The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

    Sudan’s Power Struggle: Army and Rebels Signal Possibility of Talks

    Sudan’s Power Struggle: Army and Rebels Signal Possibility of Talks

    The Awakening: Africa’s Response to Neo-Colonialism

    The Awakening: Africa’s Response to Neo-Colonialism

    Afrobeat’s Rising Star MohBad: A Cry for Justice and a Legacy Lost

    Afrobeat’s Rising Star MohBad: A Cry for Justice and a Legacy Lost

    U.S. Human Rights Agenda in Africa: Seeking A Balanced Approach

    U.S. Human Rights Agenda in Africa: Seeking A Balanced Approach

    The West African Coup Crisis: Niger at the Heart of ECOWAS Divide

    The West African Coup Crisis: Niger at the Heart of ECOWAS Divide

    Africa’s Debt Conundrum: A Dive into History, Leadership, and Financial Dynamics

    Africa’s Debt Conundrum: A Dive into History, Leadership, and Financial Dynamics

    Trending Tags

      • News
    • Documentaries
      God loves Uganda

      God loves Uganda: LGBT Exception or Religious Bigotry?

      Africa Rising: African History and the Effects of Western Policies

      Africa Rising: African History and the Effects of Western Policies

      The Desert Train: A Journey Through The Sahara To The Atlantic Coast

      The Desert Train: A Journey Through The Sahara To The Atlantic Coast

      Trending Tags

      • Features
        • All
        • Arts & Culture
        • Entertainment
        • Honour Roll
        • Lest We Forget
        Hamas, Palestinian Authority, Fatah, Gaza Strip, Israeli-Palestinian conflict

        Factionalism and the Rise of Hamas

        the-israeli-palestinian-conflict-a-historical-perspective

        The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: A Historical Perspective

        Editorial: A Letter to Rwanda

        Editorial: A Letter to Rwanda

        Afrobeats Unmasked: The Grit Behind the Glamour

        Afrobeats Unmasked: The Grit Behind the Glamour

        The Awakening: Africa’s Response to Neo-Colonialism

        The Awakening: Africa’s Response to Neo-Colonialism

        Afrobeat’s Rising Star MohBad: A Cry for Justice and a Legacy Lost

        Afrobeat’s Rising Star MohBad: A Cry for Justice and a Legacy Lost

        Ama Ata Aidoo: Ghana’s Literary Giant and Feminist Pioneer

        Ama Ata Aidoo: Ghana’s Literary Giant and Feminist Pioneer

        The West African Coup Crisis: Niger at the Heart of ECOWAS Divide

        The West African Coup Crisis: Niger at the Heart of ECOWAS Divide

        The Ripple Effects of China's Investments in Zambia A Socioeconomic Analysis

        The Ripple Effects of China’s Investments in Zambia: A Socioeconomic Analysis

      • Finance & Economics
        • All
        • Business
        • Economy
        • Tech
        Africa’s Debt Conundrum: A Dive into History, Leadership, and Financial Dynamics

        Africa’s Debt Conundrum: A Dive into History, Leadership, and Financial Dynamics

        Nigeria’s Foreign Exchange Odyssey: The Quest for Stability

        Nigeria’s Foreign Exchange Odyssey: The Quest for Stability

        The Ripple Effects of China's Investments in Zambia A Socioeconomic Analysis

        The Ripple Effects of China’s Investments in Zambia: A Socioeconomic Analysis

        A Balancing Act: Navigating the Aftermath of Fuel Subsidy Removal in Nigeria

        A Balancing Act: Navigating the Aftermath of Fuel Subsidy Removal in Nigeria

        BRICS-Africa Relations

        Deciphering the New Scramble for Africa: Unpacking the Intricacies of BRICS-Africa Relations

        Artificial Intelligence

        Artificial Intelligence: Africa’s Stance in the Global Technological Renaissance

        China’s Exploitative Mining in Africa: Environmental and Social Impacts

        China’s Exploitative Mining in Africa: Environmental and Social Impacts

        Digital Credit in Kenya: A Double-Edged Sword of Opportunity and Risk

        The Global Challenge of Poverty

        The Global Challenge of Poverty

      • Insight
        Unravelling the Tapestry of Ethnic Tension in Africa: We are all Racists!

        Unravelling the Tapestry of Ethnic Tension in Africa: We are all Racists!

        The Melancholic Symphony of Night Rain: Reflecting on JP Clark’s Portrait of Environmental Crisis in Africa

        The Melancholic Symphony of Night Rain: Reflecting on JP Clark’s Portrait of Environmental Crisis in Africa

        Rabiu Kwankwaso

        Deconstructing Rabiu Kwankwaso’s Presidential Manifesto – “My Pledges To You. The RMK2023 Blueprint”

        Poverty

        The Paradox of Poverty Amidst Plenty: Unpacking Africa’s Endemic Poverty Problem

        The Afropolitans: The Rising Global African Diaspora

        The Afropolitans: The Rising Global African Diaspora

        Nigerian Politics

        Going in Circles: A critical evaluation of Nigerian Politics

        War against corruption

        Africa’s Corruption Conundrum: Insights and Analysis

        Africa's Democracy

        Opposition Less Government The New Embodiment Of Democracy

        Trending Tags

        • Lifestyle
          • All
          • Environment
          • Health
          • Travel
          The Melancholic Symphony of Night Rain: Reflecting on JP Clark’s Portrait of Environmental Crisis in Africa

          The Melancholic Symphony of Night Rain: Reflecting on JP Clark’s Portrait of Environmental Crisis in Africa

          The Ripple Effects of China's Investments in Zambia A Socioeconomic Analysis

          The Ripple Effects of China’s Investments in Zambia: A Socioeconomic Analysis

          A Balancing Act: Navigating the Aftermath of Fuel Subsidy Removal in Nigeria

          A Balancing Act: Navigating the Aftermath of Fuel Subsidy Removal in Nigeria

          Botswana: A Journey Through the Land of the Tswanas

          Kenya Leading the Charge in Africa's Renewable Energy Revolution

          Kenya Leading the Charge in Africa’s Renewable Energy Revolution

          Sickle Cell Disease

          4 Things You Need To Know About Sickle Cell Disease

          Child Marriage in Africa: A Persistent Challenge to Sustainable Development

          Child Marriage: The Persistent Human Rights Violation Undermining African Development

          Soot pollution in Port Harcourt

          Invisible Killer: The Soot Crisis Sweeping Through Nigeria’s Oil-rich Rivers State

          Land of Punt

          Delving into the Enigma of the Ancient Land of Punt: A Historical Exploration

        • World
          • All
          • News
          the-israeli-palestinian-conflict-a-historical-perspective

          The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: A Historical Perspective

          Australia's Echoed Silence: The 'Voice' That Went Unheard

          Australia’s Echoed Silence: The ‘Voice’ That Went Unheard

          Max Verstappen’s Dramatic Ascendancy: Clinching Third Title Amidst the Chaos in Qatar

          Max Verstappen’s Dramatic Ascendancy: Clinching Third Title Amidst the Chaos in Qatar

          Escalating Tensions: Israel and Hamas at Breaking Point

          Escalating Tensions: Israel and Hamas at Breaking Point

          The Pogba Paradox: From Turin Triumphs to a Testing Testosterone Turmoil

          The Pogba Paradox: From Turin Triumphs to a Testing Testosterone Turmoil

          The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

          The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

          Scandal in the US Senate: The Shocking Allegations Against Senator Robert Menendez

          Scandal in the US Senate: The Shocking Allegations Against Senator Robert Menendez

          Australian Delegation’s Plea: The Assange Affair and Its Impact on Australia-US Relations

          Australian Delegation’s Plea: The Assange Affair and Its Impact on Australia-US Relations

          U.S. Human Rights Agenda in Africa: Seeking A Balanced Approach

          U.S. Human Rights Agenda in Africa: Seeking A Balanced Approach

        No Result
        View All Result
        • Africa
          • All
          • News
          • Politics
          Unravelling the Tapestry of Ethnic Tension in Africa: We are all Racists!

          Unravelling the Tapestry of Ethnic Tension in Africa: We are all Racists!

          Editorial: A Letter to Rwanda

          Editorial: A Letter to Rwanda

          The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

          The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

          Sudan’s Power Struggle: Army and Rebels Signal Possibility of Talks

          Sudan’s Power Struggle: Army and Rebels Signal Possibility of Talks

          The Awakening: Africa’s Response to Neo-Colonialism

          The Awakening: Africa’s Response to Neo-Colonialism

          Afrobeat’s Rising Star MohBad: A Cry for Justice and a Legacy Lost

          Afrobeat’s Rising Star MohBad: A Cry for Justice and a Legacy Lost

          U.S. Human Rights Agenda in Africa: Seeking A Balanced Approach

          U.S. Human Rights Agenda in Africa: Seeking A Balanced Approach

          The West African Coup Crisis: Niger at the Heart of ECOWAS Divide

          The West African Coup Crisis: Niger at the Heart of ECOWAS Divide

          Africa’s Debt Conundrum: A Dive into History, Leadership, and Financial Dynamics

          Africa’s Debt Conundrum: A Dive into History, Leadership, and Financial Dynamics

          Trending Tags

            • News
          • Documentaries
            God loves Uganda

            God loves Uganda: LGBT Exception or Religious Bigotry?

            Africa Rising: African History and the Effects of Western Policies

            Africa Rising: African History and the Effects of Western Policies

            The Desert Train: A Journey Through The Sahara To The Atlantic Coast

            The Desert Train: A Journey Through The Sahara To The Atlantic Coast

            Trending Tags

            • Features
              • All
              • Arts & Culture
              • Entertainment
              • Honour Roll
              • Lest We Forget
              Hamas, Palestinian Authority, Fatah, Gaza Strip, Israeli-Palestinian conflict

              Factionalism and the Rise of Hamas

              the-israeli-palestinian-conflict-a-historical-perspective

              The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: A Historical Perspective

              Editorial: A Letter to Rwanda

              Editorial: A Letter to Rwanda

              Afrobeats Unmasked: The Grit Behind the Glamour

              Afrobeats Unmasked: The Grit Behind the Glamour

              The Awakening: Africa’s Response to Neo-Colonialism

              The Awakening: Africa’s Response to Neo-Colonialism

              Afrobeat’s Rising Star MohBad: A Cry for Justice and a Legacy Lost

              Afrobeat’s Rising Star MohBad: A Cry for Justice and a Legacy Lost

              Ama Ata Aidoo: Ghana’s Literary Giant and Feminist Pioneer

              Ama Ata Aidoo: Ghana’s Literary Giant and Feminist Pioneer

              The West African Coup Crisis: Niger at the Heart of ECOWAS Divide

              The West African Coup Crisis: Niger at the Heart of ECOWAS Divide

              The Ripple Effects of China's Investments in Zambia A Socioeconomic Analysis

              The Ripple Effects of China’s Investments in Zambia: A Socioeconomic Analysis

            • Finance & Economics
              • All
              • Business
              • Economy
              • Tech
              Africa’s Debt Conundrum: A Dive into History, Leadership, and Financial Dynamics

              Africa’s Debt Conundrum: A Dive into History, Leadership, and Financial Dynamics

              Nigeria’s Foreign Exchange Odyssey: The Quest for Stability

              Nigeria’s Foreign Exchange Odyssey: The Quest for Stability

              The Ripple Effects of China's Investments in Zambia A Socioeconomic Analysis

              The Ripple Effects of China’s Investments in Zambia: A Socioeconomic Analysis

              A Balancing Act: Navigating the Aftermath of Fuel Subsidy Removal in Nigeria

              A Balancing Act: Navigating the Aftermath of Fuel Subsidy Removal in Nigeria

              BRICS-Africa Relations

              Deciphering the New Scramble for Africa: Unpacking the Intricacies of BRICS-Africa Relations

              Artificial Intelligence

              Artificial Intelligence: Africa’s Stance in the Global Technological Renaissance

              China’s Exploitative Mining in Africa: Environmental and Social Impacts

              China’s Exploitative Mining in Africa: Environmental and Social Impacts

              Digital Credit in Kenya: A Double-Edged Sword of Opportunity and Risk

              The Global Challenge of Poverty

              The Global Challenge of Poverty

            • Insight
              Unravelling the Tapestry of Ethnic Tension in Africa: We are all Racists!

              Unravelling the Tapestry of Ethnic Tension in Africa: We are all Racists!

              The Melancholic Symphony of Night Rain: Reflecting on JP Clark’s Portrait of Environmental Crisis in Africa

              The Melancholic Symphony of Night Rain: Reflecting on JP Clark’s Portrait of Environmental Crisis in Africa

              Rabiu Kwankwaso

              Deconstructing Rabiu Kwankwaso’s Presidential Manifesto – “My Pledges To You. The RMK2023 Blueprint”

              Poverty

              The Paradox of Poverty Amidst Plenty: Unpacking Africa’s Endemic Poverty Problem

              The Afropolitans: The Rising Global African Diaspora

              The Afropolitans: The Rising Global African Diaspora

              Nigerian Politics

              Going in Circles: A critical evaluation of Nigerian Politics

              War against corruption

              Africa’s Corruption Conundrum: Insights and Analysis

              Africa's Democracy

              Opposition Less Government The New Embodiment Of Democracy

              Trending Tags

              • Lifestyle
                • All
                • Environment
                • Health
                • Travel
                The Melancholic Symphony of Night Rain: Reflecting on JP Clark’s Portrait of Environmental Crisis in Africa

                The Melancholic Symphony of Night Rain: Reflecting on JP Clark’s Portrait of Environmental Crisis in Africa

                The Ripple Effects of China's Investments in Zambia A Socioeconomic Analysis

                The Ripple Effects of China’s Investments in Zambia: A Socioeconomic Analysis

                A Balancing Act: Navigating the Aftermath of Fuel Subsidy Removal in Nigeria

                A Balancing Act: Navigating the Aftermath of Fuel Subsidy Removal in Nigeria

                Botswana: A Journey Through the Land of the Tswanas

                Kenya Leading the Charge in Africa's Renewable Energy Revolution

                Kenya Leading the Charge in Africa’s Renewable Energy Revolution

                Sickle Cell Disease

                4 Things You Need To Know About Sickle Cell Disease

                Child Marriage in Africa: A Persistent Challenge to Sustainable Development

                Child Marriage: The Persistent Human Rights Violation Undermining African Development

                Soot pollution in Port Harcourt

                Invisible Killer: The Soot Crisis Sweeping Through Nigeria’s Oil-rich Rivers State

                Land of Punt

                Delving into the Enigma of the Ancient Land of Punt: A Historical Exploration

              • World
                • All
                • News
                the-israeli-palestinian-conflict-a-historical-perspective

                The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: A Historical Perspective

                Australia's Echoed Silence: The 'Voice' That Went Unheard

                Australia’s Echoed Silence: The ‘Voice’ That Went Unheard

                Max Verstappen’s Dramatic Ascendancy: Clinching Third Title Amidst the Chaos in Qatar

                Max Verstappen’s Dramatic Ascendancy: Clinching Third Title Amidst the Chaos in Qatar

                Escalating Tensions: Israel and Hamas at Breaking Point

                Escalating Tensions: Israel and Hamas at Breaking Point

                The Pogba Paradox: From Turin Triumphs to a Testing Testosterone Turmoil

                The Pogba Paradox: From Turin Triumphs to a Testing Testosterone Turmoil

                The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

                The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

                Scandal in the US Senate: The Shocking Allegations Against Senator Robert Menendez

                Scandal in the US Senate: The Shocking Allegations Against Senator Robert Menendez

                Australian Delegation’s Plea: The Assange Affair and Its Impact on Australia-US Relations

                Australian Delegation’s Plea: The Assange Affair and Its Impact on Australia-US Relations

                U.S. Human Rights Agenda in Africa: Seeking A Balanced Approach

                U.S. Human Rights Agenda in Africa: Seeking A Balanced Approach

              No Result
              View All Result
              Africa360 Degrees
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home Africa

              Sudan’s Power Struggle: Army and Rebels Signal Possibility of Talks

              Ayo Obafemi by Ayo Obafemi
              23 September 2023
              in News
              Reading Time: 4 mins read
              0
              Sudan’s Power Struggle: Army and Rebels Signal Possibility of Talks

              In a rare move of tentative diplomacy amidst Sudan’s ongoing turmoil, the country’s army chief has hinted at a willingness for dialogue with the rebel commander, thus creating ripples of hope in a conflict that has witnessed brutal ramifications for civilians.

              A Nation Torn Asunder

              Sudan has been embroiled in a devastating internal conflict since April, a tragedy which, according to the United Nations, has led to the unfortunate demise of over 5,000 individuals. The strife has also uprooted over five million from their homes, painting a bleak picture of a nation grappling with deep internal schisms.

              General Abdel Fattah al-Burhan, who spearheads the Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF), and the rebel leader, Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo of the Rapid Support Forces (RSF), have been at the epicentre of this confrontation. The seismic rift between the two factions reverberated globally when Gen. Burhan expressed, during a BBC interview, his conditional readiness for talks, marking a potential departure from the longstanding deadlock.

              Seeking Legitimacy on the World Stage

              Gen. Burhan’s address to the UN General Assembly in New York revealed this revelation. Having assumed power through a coup in 2021, the General is on a quest for international validation. His tour aims at procuring support and establishing legitimacy despite criticisms stemming from his unwillingness to transition power to civilian oversight.

              In the interview, Gen. Burhan rejected claims, upheld by the UN and various charities, that his troops were indiscriminately bombarding civilian regions. Asserting confidence in imminent victory, he also acknowledged the move of his operational base to Port Sudan due to the escalating skirmishes in Khartoum.

              Conditions for Dialogue

              The caveat for dialogue, as elucidated by Gen. Burhan, rests on Gen. Dagalo’s adherence to earlier commitments. Earlier this year, both parties had previously vowed to safeguard civilians during discussions in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.

              Gen. Burhan emphasised the precondition, “We are ready to engage in negotiations.” The sentiment was reciprocated when Gen. Dagalo, commonly called ‘Hemedti’, voiced his openness for political dialogue via a video message. Notably, while both leaders have previously mooted the idea of ceasefires, a tangible reduction in hostilities still needs to be discovered.

              A Nation’s Hope Amidst Despair

              Gen. Burhan fervently negated the grim prognosis of Sudan’s becoming a failed state akin to Somalia or fragmenting like Libya. He reiterated his faith in Sudan’s unity, vouching for the nation’s collective will to quash the rebellion through peaceful negotiations or combative means.

              However, the UN has cast aspersions on the likelihood of either faction achieving a conclusive military triumph.

              The Toll on Civilians

              Khartoum, Sudan’s capital, has borne the brunt of this war, with multiple reports suggesting that innocent civilians are being caught in the crossfire, primarily through indiscriminate aerial bombings by SAF. Gen. Burhan vehemently denies these allegations, pointing the finger at rebel forces for orchestrating such narratives.

              However, the former UN special representative to Sudan, Volker Perthes, highlighted to the Security Council that these bombardments are primarily executed by entities possessing an air force, thus indirectly implicating SAF.

              As Sudan navigates this tumultuous chapter, the potential for dialogue offers a glimmer of hope. While the path to peace is fraught with challenges, the mere suggestion of talks underscores the need for a resolution that prioritises the welfare and aspirations of the Sudanese populace.

              Tags: #ArmyRebelTalks#CiviliansAtRisk#GenBurhan#GenDagalo#KhartoumClashes#PathToPeace#PoliticalDialogue#SudanConflict#SudanCrisis#UNIntervention
              ShareShareSendSend
              Previous Post

              The Awakening: Africa’s Response to Neo-Colonialism

              Next Post

              The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

              Ayo Obafemi

              Ayo Obafemi

              Ayo, the Chief Editor of Africa360 Degrees, boasts a robust background in Data analysis. Ayo is adept at discerning patterns in global politics, especially those impacting Africa. His passion for geopolitics, cultivated since his childhood in Nigeria, aligns with his belief in the transformative power of information. Ayo has the drive to deliver accurate and impartial analyses of Africa's political landscape. In his role at Africa360 Degrees, Ayo synergises his Data analysis prowess with his geopolitical interests, producing engaging, well-researched content. His commitment to effecting positive change through reliable information establishes him as a respected voice in the dialogue surrounding Africa's evolving political scene.

              Next Post
              The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

              The UN Sanctions Deployment of Kenyan-led Forces to Tackle Haitian Gang Crisis

              The Pogba Paradox: From Turin Triumphs to a Testing Testosterone Turmoil

              The Pogba Paradox: From Turin Triumphs to a Testing Testosterone Turmoil

              Afrobeats Unmasked: The Grit Behind the Glamour

              Afrobeats Unmasked: The Grit Behind the Glamour

              Escalating Tensions: Israel and Hamas at Breaking Point

              Escalating Tensions: Israel and Hamas at Breaking Point

              Max Verstappen’s Dramatic Ascendancy: Clinching Third Title Amidst the Chaos in Qatar

              Max Verstappen's Dramatic Ascendancy: Clinching Third Title Amidst the Chaos in Qatar

              Subscribe
              Login
              Notify of
              guest
              guest
              0 Comments
              Inline Feedbacks
              View all comments
              • Trending
              • Comments
              • Latest
              The Ripple Effects of China's Investments in Zambia A Socioeconomic Analysis

              The Ripple Effects of China’s Investments in Zambia: A Socioeconomic Analysis

              13 June 2023
              The Imperialist Agenda of Western Journalists during African Elections A Nigerian Case Study

              The Imperialist Agenda of Western Journalists during African Elections: A Nigerian Case Study

              28 March 2023
              Profiling 2023 Nigerian Presidential Candidates: Peter Gregory Obi

              Profiling 2023 Nigerian Presidential Candidates: Peter Gregory Obi

              13 January 2023
              The Biafran War: A Deeply Tragic Chapter in Nigeria’s History

              The Biafran War: A Deeply Tragic Chapter in Nigeria’s History

              0
              Sickle Cell Disease

              4 Things You Need To Know About Sickle Cell Disease

              0
              Nigerian Politics

              Going in Circles: A critical evaluation of Nigerian Politics

              0

              The Duality of Morality: Examining Western Values Through African Eyes

              3 December 2023

              From Poetic Warnings to Political Realities: Unpacking Apathy under Tinubu’s Reign

              3 December 2023

              Beyond the Religious Facade: Unravelling the Complex Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

              3 December 2023

              Categories

              • Africa
              • Arts & Culture
              • Business
              • Documentaries
              • Economy
              • Editorial
              • Entertainment
              • Environment
              • Features
              • Finance & Economics
              • Health
              • Honour Roll
              • Insight
              • Lest We Forget
              • Lifestyle
              • News
              • News
              • Politics
              • Sports
              • Tech
              • Travel
              • Uncategorized
              • World

              Archives

              © 2023 Africa360 Degrees News - We are a Premium News, Politics, Insight, & Analysis Site .

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Africa
              • Documentaries
              • Features
              • Finance & Economics
                • Business
                • Crypto
                • Tech
              • Insight
              • Lifestyle
                • Health
                • Travel
              • World

              © 2023 Africa360 Degrees News - We are a Premium News, Politics, Insight, & Analysis Site .

              Welcome Back!

              OR

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In
              wpDiscuz
              0
              0
              Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
              ()
              x
              | Reply